System Types
What is meant by a "type" of Fire Alarm system?
Types of Fire Alarm systems should not be mistaken for categories of Fire Alarm systems. The type refers to the technical functionality of the system and not to the extent/application of its coverage.
What are the three types of Fire Alarm systems?
The three types of Fire Alarm systems are as follows:
- Conventional
- Addressable
- Wireless
All three types of systems have both upsides and downsides. Choosing the right system for your application can be challenging, but accuracy is essential for safety and compliance.
Conventional Systems
What is a conventional system?
A conventional Fire Alarm system is a wired system in which each detection zone has its own cable running from a central control panel.
Conventional systems operate in a basic manner and do not provide device-specific information. These panels most commonly monitor a cable's resistance to determine whether there is a fire. They are unable to identify specific devices or provide detailed information about fault and fire signals.
Advantages
Some of the key advantages of a conventional system are listed below:
- Cost → Conventional systems tend to be cheaper than other types of Fire Alarm systems and require less labor to install than addressable systems, particularly in smaller buildings.
- Simplicity → Conventional systems are very easy for end users to understand and operate.
- Compatibility → Conventional systems were common before the loop wiring method became more widespread, so old wiring can often be directly reused with minimal adjustment.
- Reliability → Conventional systems contain simpler technology, making them more reliable for smaller installations.
Drawbacks
Some of the key drawbacks of conventional systems are listed below:
- More Wiring Required → Each zone requires separate wiring, leading to more cabling, higher installation costs, and increased complexity in large buildings.
- Limited Location Identification → The system can only identify the general zone where an alarm has been triggered, not the exact device.
- Troubleshooting → Identifying faults on a conventional system is more difficult than on an addressable system, potentially increasing maintenance costs.
- Limited Integration with Other Systems → Conventional systems have fewer options for integration with modern building management and emergency response systems.
- Difficult Expansion → Adding new devices often requires additional wiring and control panel upgrades, making system expansion costly and time-consuming.
Addressable Systems
What is an addressable system?
An addressable fire alarm system is a type of fire detection system where each device (such as smoke detectors, heat detectors, and manual call points) has a unique address. This means the control panel can identify exactly which device has been triggered, allowing for precise detection of fires and faults.
Advantages
Some of the key advantages of an addressable Fire Alarm system are listed below:
- Precise Location Identification → Pinpoints the exact detector that has been triggered.
- Reduced Wiring → Uses a loop instead of individual circuits for each zone.
- Advanced Diagnostics → Can monitor device health and detect faults early.
- Flexibility → Suitable for large and complex buildings like hospitals, schools, and office buildings.
- Capability → Allows advanced Cause & Effect programming to customize system responses for specific fire safety requirements.
Drawbacks
Some of the key disadvantages of an addressable Fire Alarm system are listed below:
- Higher Initial Cost → Addressable systems are more expensive to purchase and install compared to conventional fire alarm systems.
- Complex Installation & Programming → Requires specialized knowledge to configure addresses, set up communication loops, and program the system correctly.
- More Expensive Maintenance & Repairs → Since the system is more advanced, troubleshooting and repairing faults may require specialized technicians, increasing maintenance costs.
- Compatibility Issues → Addressable systems often require specific proprietary equipment, limiting flexibility when adding new devices or replacing faulty ones.
- Longer Configuration Time → Setting up an addressable system involves assigning addresses to devices, programming responses, and testing, which takes more time than conventional systems.
Wireless Systems
What is a wireless system?
A wireless fire alarm system operates similarly to an addressable system but does not require physical wiring between devices and the control panel. Instead, wireless detectors, call points, and alarms communicate via radio signals, reducing installation complexity and making them ideal for buildings where running cables is difficult or impractical.
Advantages
Some of the key advantages of a wireless Fire Alarm system are listed below:
- Quick Installation → No need for extensive cabling, reducing labor costs and installation time.
- Flexibility → Ideal for historical buildings, temporary sites, or locations where wiring is challenging.
- Scalability → Easily expandable without major rewiring or infrastructure changes.
- Aesthetics → No visible cables, making it more suitable for buildings where maintaining visual appeal is important.
Drawbacks
Some of the key disadvantages of a wireless Fire Alarm system are listed below:
- Higher Initial Cost → Wireless devices are generally more expensive than their wired counterparts.
- Battery Dependency → Devices rely on batteries that require regular maintenance and replacement to ensure functionality.
- Signal Interference → Wireless systems may experience interference from other radio-frequency sources, affecting reliability.
- Limited Range → Large buildings may require signal repeaters to ensure reliable communication across all devices.
- Security Concerns → Wireless systems are susceptible to hacking or signal jamming, although modern encryption protocols have mitigated these risks.